ATHLON WEEK 11 PICKS | November 12, 2016 | ||
Game Picks – Dasol Mashaka | |||
Time | Matchup | Pick | Winner |
Saturday, November 12, 2016 | |||
1:00pm | Kentucky at Tennessee | Tennessee | |
1:00pm | California at Wash. St. | Wash. St. | |
1:00pm | Minnesota at Nebraska | Nebraska | |
1:00pm | Illinois at Wisconsin | Wisconsin | |
1:00pm | Wake Forest at Louisville | Louisville | |
1:00pm | Auburn at Georgia | Auburn | |
1:00pm | Ole Miss at Texas A&M | Texas A&M | |
1:00pm | LSU at Arkansas | LSU | |
1:00pm | Ohio St. at Maryland | Ohio St. | |
1:00pm | Vanderbilt at Missouri | Vanderbilt | |
1:00pm | West Virginia at Texas | West Virginia | |
1:00pm | Pittsburgh at Clemson | Clemson | |
1:00pm | Baylor at Oklahoma | Oklahoma | |
1:00pm | Penn St. at Indiana | Penn St. | |
1:00pm | Georgia Tech at Virginia Tech | Virginia Tech | |
1:00pm | South Carolina at Florida | Florida | |
1:00pm | Texas Tech at Oklahoma St. | Oklahoma St. | |
1:00pm | Mississippi St. at Alabama | Alabama | |
1:00pm | Michigan at Iowa | Michigan | |
Bonus Game | |||
Time | Matchup | Pick | Winner |
Saturday, November 12, 2016 | |||
1:00pm | USC at Washington | Washington 33 – 27 | |
ATHLON WEEK 10 PICKS – RESULTS | November 5, 2016 | ||
Game Picks – Dasol Mashaka | W 17 – L 3 | ||
Time ET | Matchup | Pick | Winner |
Saturday, November 5, 2016 | |||
11:30am | Navy at Notre Dame | Navy | Navy |
12:00pm | Vanderbilt at Auburn | Auburn | Auburn |
12:00pm | Wisconsin at Northwestern | Wisconsin | Wisconsin |
12:00pm | Louisville at Boston College | Louisville | Louisville |
12:00pm | Texas A&M at Mississippi St. | Texas A&M | Mississippi St |
12:30pm | Georgia Tech at N. Carolina | N. Carolina | N. Carolina |
3:30pm | Maryland at Michigan | Michigan | Michigan |
3:30pm | TCU at Baylor | Baylor | TCU |
3:30pm | Virginia Tech at Duke | Virginia Tech | Virginia Tech |
3:30pm | Florida at Arkansas | Florida | Arkansas |
3:30pm | Oklahoma St. at Kansas St. | Oklahoma St. | Oklahoma St. |
3:30pm | Syracuse at Clemson | Clemson | Clemson |
4:00pm | Missouri at South Carolina | South Carolina | South Carolina |
4:00pm | Arizona at Wash. St. | Wash. St. | Wash. St. |
7:00pm | Florida St. at N.C. State | Florida St. | Florida St. |
7:30pm | Georgia at Kentucky | Georgia | Georgia |
7:30pm | Iowa at Penn St. | Penn St. | Penn St. |
8:00pm | Nebraska at Ohio St. | Ohio St. | Ohio St. |
10:30pm | Washington at California | Washington | Washington |
Bonus Game | |||
Time | Matchup | Pick | Winner |
Saturday, November 5, 2016 | |||
8:00pm | Alabama at LSU | Alabama 24 – 13 | Alabama 10-0 |
Author: cfminded
College football fan since age 10; listened to games on the radio before most games were televised.
Preseason poll analyst for last 15 years, beating most media, magazines and sportscaster pollsters during this period
Degrees in architecture and mathematics; retired from building industry
CFMinded.com Dasol Mashaka November 4, 2016
Nick Saban at Alabama is ranked No. 1a in college football and, Urban Meyer at Ohio State is ranked No. 1b. All the other 126 Division I Subdivision (FBS) coaches are ranked No. 2 or lower. Three other coaches have their eyes on No. 1 in a hurry.
Jim Harbaugh at the University of Michigan wants No. 1b against Ohio State November 26th now and No. 1a in the playoff against Alabama. This is only Harbaugh’s second year at Michigan after his overnight success in the NFL. “Not so fast my friend. ” says two other coaches.
Chris Peterson at the University of Washington is climbing quickly. At Boise State, he has surpassed the northwest trailblazing of Urban Meyer who moved from Utah to Florida. Peterson is the only PAC 12 undefeated team in just his third Season. He already beat powerhouses like Oklahoma and Oregon while at Boise State. He could surpass Nick Saban and Urban Meyer for 2016 only if Washington gets to the playoff.
Ed Orgeron at LSU is the sleeper. His reputation as the best interim head coach has him in a position to get one leg up on Nick Saban for LSU ambushes Alabama November 5th. Alabama has five advantages LSU must overcome: 1. Best Coach, 2. Best Overall Team, 3. Best Quarterback, 4. Best Coaching Staff, 5. Best Experience Playing Under One Scheme (three years verses LSU’s three games). LSU has the advantaged of the most fired up home team and crowds that Alabama can’t imagine.
This speculation is why we love college football and why they play the game.
Dasol Mashaka November 4, 2016
ATHLON WEEK 10 PICKS | November 5, 2016 | ||
Game Picks – Dasol Mashaka | |||
Time ET | Matchup | Pick | Winner |
Saturday, November 5, 2016 | |||
11:30am | Navy at Notre Dame | Navy | |
12:00pm | Vanderbilt at Auburn | Auburn | |
12:00pm | Wisconsin at Northwestern | Wisconsin | |
12:00pm | Louisville at Boston College | Louisville | |
12:00pm | Texas A&M at Mississippi St. | Texas A&M | |
12:30pm | Georgia Tech at N. Carolina | N. Carolina | |
3:30pm | Maryland at Michigan | Michigan | |
3:30pm | TCU at Baylor | Baylor | |
3:30pm | Virginia Tech at Duke | Virginia Tech | |
3:30pm | Florida at Arkansas | Florida | |
3:30pm | Oklahoma St. at Kansas St. | Oklahoma St. | |
3:30pm | Syracuse at Clemson | Clemson | |
4:00pm | Missouri at South Carolina | South Carolina | |
4:00pm | Arizona at Wash. St. | Wash. St. | |
7:00pm | Florida St. at N.C. State | Florida St. | |
7:30pm | Georgia at Kentucky | Georgia | |
7:30pm | Iowa at Penn St. | Penn St. | |
8:00pm | Nebraska at Ohio St. | Ohio St. | |
10:30pm | Washington at California | Washington | |
Bonus Game | |||
Time | Matchup | Pick | Winner |
Saturday, November 5, 2016 | |||
8:00pm | Alabama at LSU | Alabama 24 – 13 | |
Idle | |||
Utah | |||
ATHLON WEEK 9 PICKS | October 29, 2016 | ||
Game Picks – Dasol Mashaka | W 15 – L 5 | ||
Time | Matchup | Pick | Winner |
Saturday, October 29, 2016 | |||
12:00pm | Kentucky at Missouri | Kentucky | Kentucky |
12:00pm | West Virginia at Oklahoma St. | West Virginia | Oklahoma St. |
12:00pm | Louisville at Virginia | Louisville | Louisville |
12:00pm | Penn St. at Purdue | Penn St. | Penn St. |
12:00pm | Michigan at Michigan St. | Michigan | Michigan |
3:30pm | Northwestern at Ohio St. | Ohio St. | Ohio St. |
3:30pm | Georgia at Florida | Florida | Florida |
3:30pm | Washington at Utah | Washington | Washington |
3:30pm | Baylor at Texas | Baylor | Texas |
3:30pm | Miami at Notre Dame | Miami | Notre Dame |
4:00pm | Arizona St. at Oregon | Arizona St. | Oregon |
7:00pm | Boise St. at Wyoming | Boise St. | Wyoming |
7:00pm | Kansas at Oklahoma | Oklahoma | Oklahoma |
7:00pm | Nebraska at Wisconsin | Wisconsin | Wisconsin |
7:15pm | Auburn at Ole Miss | Auburn | Auburn |
7:15pm | Tennessee at South Carolina | Tennessee | South Carolina |
7:30pm | New Mexico St. at Texas A&M | Texas A&M | Texas A&M |
8:00pm | Tulsa at Memphis | Memphis | Tulsa |
11:00pm | Stanford at Arizona | Stanford | Stanford |
Bonus Game | |||
Time | Matchup | Pick | Winner |
Saturday, October 29, 2016 | |||
8:00pm | Clemson at Florida St. | Clemson 27 – 17 | Clemson 37 – 34 |
ATHLON WEEK 8 PICKS | October 22, 2016 | ||
Game Picks – Dasol Mashaka | W 14 – L 6 | ||
Time | Matchup | Pick | Winner |
Saturday, October 22, 2016 | |||
12:00pm | N.C. State at Louisville | Louisville | Louisville |
12:00pm | Texas at Kansas St. | Texas | Kansas St. |
12:00pm | Wisconsin at Iowa | Wisconsin | Wisconsin |
1:00pm | Arizona St. at Washington St. | Washington St. | Washington St. |
3:00pm | N. Carolina at Virginia | N. Carolina | N. Carolina |
3:00pm | Colorado at Stanford | Stanford | Colorado |
3:30pm | Purdue at Nebraska | Nebraska | Nebraska |
3:30pm | TCU at West Virginia | West Virginia | West Virginia |
3:30pm | Illinois at Michigan | Michigan | Michigan |
3:30pm | Texas A&M at Alabama | Alabama | Alabama |
3:30pm | Memphis at Navy | Navy | Navy |
4:00pm | Middle Tennessee at Missouri | Missouri | Middle Tennessee |
4:00pm | Utah at UCLA | Utah | Utah |
6:00pm | Arkansas at Auburn | Auburn | Auburn |
6:30pm | Oregon St. at Washington | Washington | Washington |
7:00pm | Houston at SMU | Houston | SMU |
7:30pm | Mississippi St. at Kentucky | Mississippi St. | Kentucky |
8:00pm | Oklahoma at Texas Tech | Oklahoma | Oklahoma |
9:00pm | Ole Miss at LSU | LSU | LSU |
Bonus Game | |||
Time | Matchup | Pick | Winner |
Saturday, October 22, 2016 | |||
8:00pm | Ohio St. at Penn St. | Ohio St. 45 – 13 | Penn St. 21 – 24 |
ATHLON WEEK 7 PICKS | October 14, 2016 | |||
Game Picks – Dasol Mashaka | ||||
Time ET | Matchup | Pick | Odds | |
Saturday, October 15, 2016 | ||||
12:00pm | N.C. State at Clemson | Clemson | (-17.5) | |
12:00pm | Kansas St. at Oklahoma | Oklahoma | (-13.5) | |
12:00pm | Vanderbilt at Georgia | Georgia | (-14) | |
12:00pm | West Virginia at Texas Tech | West Virginia | (-1) | |
12:30pm | Pittsburgh at Virginia | Pittsburgh | (-3.5) | |
3:30pm | Nebraska at Indiana | Nebraska | (-3.5) | |
3:30pm | Wake Forest at Florida St. | Florida St. | (-21.5) Wake Forest | |
3:30pm | Alabama at Tennessee | Alabama | (-13) | |
3:30pm | Northwestern at Michigan St. | Michigan St. | (-6.5) | |
3:30pm | USC at Arizona | USC | (-9) | |
3:30pm | N. Carolina at Miami | Miami | (-6.5) | |
3:45pm | Virginia Tech at Syracuse | Virginia Tech | (-27) Syracuse | |
4:00pm | Missouri at Florida | Florida | (-13.5) | |
4:00pm | Utah at Oregon St. | Utah | (-9) | |
7:00pm | Ole Miss at Arkansas | Ole Miss | (-7.5) | |
7:30pm | Stanford at Notre Dame | Notre Dame | (-3) | |
7:30pm | Southern Miss. at LSU | LSU | (-25) | |
8:00pm | Arizona St. at Colorado | Colorado | (-13) Arizona St | |
10:30pm | UCLA at Washington St. | Washington St. | (-7) | |
Bonus Game | ||||
Time | Matchup | Pick | Odds | |
Saturday, October 15, 2016 | ||||
8:00pm | Ohio St. at Wisconsin | Ohio St. 24 – 17 | (-11) | |
Idle | ||||
Auburn | ||||
Navy | ||||
Preseason Polls Top 25 Standings After Week 6 | ||||
Dasol | AP | Coaches | Phil Steele | Athlon |
2nd tied | 3rd | 2nd tied | 2nd tied | 1st |
Note: Week 6 rankings are the average of the AP and Coaches Polls. |
cfminfed-week-6-picks_10-06-16
ATHLON WEEK 6 PICKS 10-07-16 | October 6, 2016 | ||
Game Picks – Dasol Mashaka | |||
Time ET | Matchup | Pick | Winner |
Saturday, October 8, 2016 | |||
12:00pm | Oklahoma 46 at Texas 38 | Oklahoma | |
12:00pm | Auburn at Mississippi St. | Auburn | |
12:00pm | Notre Dame at N.C. State | Notre Dame | |
3:00pm | Houston at Navy | Houston | |
3:30pm | Iowa St. at Oklahoma St. | Oklahoma St. | |
3:30pm | Indiana at Ohio St. | Ohio St. | |
3:30pm | Virginia Tech at N. Carolina | N. Carolina | |
3:30pm | Tennessee 21 at Texas A&M 38 | Texas A&M | |
3:30pm | BYU at Michigan St. | Michigan St. | |
4:00pm | Vanderbilt at Kentucky | Kentucky | |
4:00pm | Colorado 26 at USC 35 | USC | |
7:00pm | Michigan at Rutgers | Michigan | |
7:30pm | Washington at Oregon | Washington | |
7:30pm | Georgia at South Carolina | Georgia | |
8:00pm | Florida St. 28 at Miami 34 | Miami | |
10:00pm | Arizona at Utah | Utah | |
10:30pm | Washington St. 35 at Stanford 34 | Washington St. | |
10:30pm | UCLA at Arizona St. | UCLA | |
Bonus Game | |||
Time | Matchup | Pick | Winner |
Saturday, October 8, 2016 | |||
7:00pm | Alabama 40 at Arkansas 35 | Alabama | |
Idle | Winner | ||
Louisville | |||
Wisconsin | |||
Nebraska | |||
Baylor | |||
Old Miss | |||
Florida | |||
LSU |
The Preseason CFMinded Poll beats AP, Coaches and Athlon polls after 5 weeks of college football. This is based on the reference poll being an average of the October 2, 2016 AP and Coaches top 25 rankings.
CFMinded Poll has 3 exact ranking of teams, which is most among the 5 preseason polls.
cfminded-college-football-preseason-polls-comparison-10-02-16
My Preseason Poll leads the AP/Coaches Polls average by two teams. I picked Washington and Utah to play in the Pac 12 Championship Game, both undefeated. The same goes for Michigan and Clemson in the ACC and Big 10. Oklahoma and LSU coaches have let me down on the Big 12 and SEC, but can still come back – maybe, maybe, maybe.
Game Picks – Week 5
Time | Match-up | Pick |
---|---|---|
Friday, September 30, 2016 (Eastern Time) | ||
9:00pm | Stanford @ Washington* | Washington odds 3.5 |
Time | Match-up | Pick |
---|---|---|
Saturday, October 1, 2016 | ||
12:00pm | Notre Dame @ Syracuse | Notre Dame odds 10.5 |
12:00pm | Baylor @ Iowa St. | Baylor odds 17 |
12:00pm | Rutgers @ Ohio St. | Ohio St. odds 38 |
12:00pm | Northwestern @ Iowa | Iowa odds 3.5 |
12:00pm | Florida @ Vanderbilt | Florida odds 10.5 |
12:00pm | Miami @ Georgia Tech | Miami odds 7.5 |
12:00pm | Texas @ Oklahoma St. | Texas odds 2.5 OK St |
3:30pm | Wisconsin @ Michigan | Michigan odds 10 |
3:30pm | Kansas St. @ West Virginia | West Virginia odds 2.5 |
3:30pm | Tennessee @ Georgia | Tennessee odds 3 |
3:30pm | N. Carolina @ Florida St. | Florida St. odds 10.5 |
4:00pm | Texas A&M @ South Carolina | Texas A&M odds 18.5 |
5:00pm | Oklahoma @ TCU | TCU odds 3.5 |
6:00pm | Utah @ California | Utah odds 2.5 Cal |
7:00pm | Memphis @ Ole Miss | Ole Miss odds 14.5 |
7:00pm | Kentucky @ Alabama | Alabama odds 35.5 |
7:30pm | Missouri @ LSU | LSU odds |
8:30pm | Arizona St. @ USC | USC odds 10 |
10:30pm | Arizona @ UCLA | UCLA odds 13.5 |
Time | Bonus Match-up | Pick |
---|---|---|
8:00pm | Louisville @ Clemson | Louisville 33 – 27 odds 2 |
* – Not on Athlon Challenge List ! – Important Games
I pulled ahead of the Preseason AP and Coaches Polls in week 4: AP/Coaches 11, Even 1, Dasol 13. Also, I picked 16 of 22 game winners – 73%.
Game Picks – Week 4 [Results: Won 16, Lost 6]
Thursday, September 22, 2016
Clemson at Georgia Tech*
Friday, September 23, 2016
USC 15 at Utah 29 *!! [USC 27 at Utah 31 – won]
Saturday, September 24, 2016
Kent St. at Alabama [Alabama – won]
Georgia 30 at Ole Miss 39 !!! [Georgia 15 at Ole Miss 45 – won]
Florida St. 34 at South Florida 27 ! [Florida St. 55 at South Florida 35 – won]
Wisconsin 19 at Michigan St. 36 !!! [Wisconsin 30 at Michigan St. 6 – lost] East Carolina at Virginia Tech [Virginia Tech – won]
Mississippi St. at Massachusetts [Mississippi St. – won]
Duke at Notre Dame [Duke at Notre Dame – lost]
Pittsburgh 23 at N. Carolina 37 !! [Pittsburgh 36 at N. Carolina 37 – won]
Penn St. at Michigan [Michigan – won]
Florida 22 at Tennessee 25 !!! [Florida 28 at Tennessee 38 – won]
Vanderbilt at W. Kentucky [Vanderbilt at W. Kentucky – won]
Colorado at Oregon [Colorado – lost]
LSU 18 at Auburn 17 !! [LSU 13 at Auburn 18 – lost]
South Carolina at Kentucky [South Carolina – lost]
Oklahoma St. 33 at Baylor 36 !!! [Oklahoma St. 24 at Baylor 35 – won]
Nebraska at Northwestern [Nebraska – won]
Louisville at Marshall [Louisville – won]
Stanford 23 at UCLA 13 !! [Stanford 22 at UCLA 13 – won]
Texas A&M 34 at Arkansas 30 !!! [Texas A&M 45 at Arkansas 24 – won]
California at Arizona St. [California – lost]
Washington 23 at Arizona 7 [Washington 35 at Arizona 28 – won]
* – Not on Athlon Challenge List ! – Important Games
Excuse me for preseason picks:
– Thinking that Oklahoma and LSU coaching staffs would improve; LSU with 17 of 22 starters returning
– Thinking that Oklahoma’s starters last year were better than Ohio State’s second stringers last year; Oklahoma has 13 starters returning, and Ohio State only 6.
I am behind of the Preseason AP and Coaches Polls, but I should catch up this week: AP/Coaches 14, Even 1, Dasol 10
Game Picks – Week 4
Thursday, September 22, 2016
Clemson at Georgia Tech*
Friday, September 23, 2016
12:00pm USC 15 at Utah 29 *!!
Saturday, September 24, 2016
12:00pm Kent St. at Alabama
12:00pm Georgia 30 at Ole Miss 39 !!!
12:00pm Florida St. 34 at South Florida 27 !
12:00pm Wisconsin 19 at Michigan St. 36 !!!
12:30pm East Carolina at Virginia Tech [Virginia Tech]
3:30pm Mississippi St. at Massachusetts [Mississippi St.]
3:30pm Duke at Notre Dame [Notre Dame]
3:30pm Pittsburgh 23 at N. Carolina 37 !!
3:30pm Penn St. at Michigan [Michigan]
3:30pm Florida 22 at Tennessee 25 !!!
4:30pm Vanderbilt at W. Kentucky [Vanderbilt]
5:30pm Colorado at Oregon [Oregon]
6:00pm LSU 18 at Auburn 17 !!
7:30pm South Carolina at Kentucky [South Carolina]
7:30pm Oklahoma St. 33 at Baylor 36 !!!
7:30pm Nebraska at Northwestern [Nebraska]*!!
8:00pm Louisville at Marshall [Louisville]
8:00pm Stanford 23 at UCLA 13 !!
9:00pm Texas A&M 34 at Arkansas 30 !!!
10:00pm California at Arizona St. [California]
10:30pm Washington 23 at Arizona 7
* – Not on Athlon Challenge List ! – Important Games
by Mashaka
You can beat the media, magazines and sportscasters preseason polls by following the criteria provided herein. I have used this criteria to defeat most pollsters for the past 15 years.
Do not let anyone fool you by saying they can predict college football games. There are too many 18 and 19 year old youngsters that determine the outcome of games. So be real. How dependable and predictable were you at 19? My point exactly!
Furthermore, the pollsters that publish the most detail team data get it very wrong. For example, most did not rank the following teams in the 2015 preseason top 40: 8. Houston, 9. Iowa, 11. Michigan. 15. North Carolina. Many had the following teams ranked higher than No. 15: 2. Clemson, 5. Oklahoma, 10. Old Miss.
Criteria Section 1
- Previous Season’s Record
Last season’s record is the baseline. Teams will do better or worse this year depending on unforeseen factors and primarily the factors listed below.
- Players Lost and Gained
The number and quality of starting players lost or gained is the biggest factor, because new players are unproven. The quarterback receives more weight in the analysis. Few teams are the exception. The offensive and defensive unit’s strengths and weaknesses are the second biggest factor.
- Quarterbacks Dominate
The quarterback receives more weight depending on the division and the offensive scheme. Two of the few exceptions are Alabama and Michigan, who are less quarterback dependent. Teams like Oregon, Auburn and Baylor are heavily quarterback dependent.
- Head Coaches and Coordinators
Ranking the coaches is critical, because they have significant weight in wins and losses. I believe in the old phrase, “I can take mine and beat yours. I can take yours and beat mine.” For example, Kansas State’s Coach Snyder often beats teams with superior talent.
“The tie could be broke this year between Nick Sabin and Urban Meyer on who the best college football head coach is”
If Nick Sabin wins the national championship with only 3 defensive starters returning
If Urban Meyer can win a game in the national championship playoff with only 3 offensive starters returning and only 3 defensive starters returning
- Strength of Schedule and Back-to-Back Tough Opponents
Teams with top coaching staffs and more time to prepare may defeat tough opponents with less time to prepare. A team that plays 5 tough opponents in a row is another story. Take for instance the schedules of Stanford and Oklahoma who have equally tough schedules. Stanford has 5 tough games in a row without a bye week. Oklahoma has no tough back-to-back opponents in the regular season. Stanford is not expected to make the division championships, and Oklahoma is projected to be in the national championship playoffs.
Criteria Section 2
- Previous Season’s Record
A majority of teams ranked in the 2016 preseason top 4 had a baseline ranking of 1 through 6 in 2015. Only LSU and Michigan were ranked higher than 10 in 2015. The chart below will show why these 2 teams jumped into the 2016 preseason top 4 ranking.
Preseason Polls 2016 | ||||
AP & Coaches* | Mashaka | Final 2015 | See Criteria: | |
Alabama | 1 | 5 | 1 | 3, 5 |
Clemson | 2 | 3 | 2 | 2, 3, 5 |
Oklahoma | 3 | 1 | 5 | 3, 5 |
Florida St | 4 | 6 | 6 | 3, 5 |
Ohio State | 5 | 7 | 4 | 2, 5 |
LSU | 5 | 2 | 16 | 2, 5 |
Michigan | 7 | 4 | 11 | 2, 5 |
* – Averaged |
2. Players Lost and Gained
Oklahoma is my No. 1 team, because they have a balanced team of players returning with no significant loss of players. The others factors are no back-to-back tough opponents and assuming Alabama will not make the playoffs. Nick Sabin’s team won the national championship in the 2015 season with only 3 returning offense players. Getting to the playoffs in 2016, with only 3 returning on defense 3 back-to-back tough opponents, is another matter.
Returning Starters 2016 | ||||
QB | Offense | Defense | Total | |
Alabama | New | 5 | 6 | 11 |
Clemson | Super Star | 8 | 4 | 12 |
Oklahoma | All Star | 7 | 6 | 13 |
Florida St | New | 11 | 6 | 17 |
Ohio State | Star | 3 | 3 | 6 |
LSU | Return | 8 | 9 | 17 |
Michigan | New | 8 | 6 | 14 |
- Quarterbacks Dominate
Here is how quarterbacks affect the expected national championship playoff teams:
Alabama (-) A new quarterback doesn’t weigh much in the winning equation.
Clemson (+ + +) Their returning super star quarterback gives this team a huge edge.
Oklahoma (+ + +) This returning all-star quarterback makes all the difference.
Florida State (-) The new quarterback will make or break this experienced team.
Ohio State (+ +) There returning star quarterback is the only hope for this team which returns on 3 starting players on offense and 3 on defense.
LSU (-) The returning quarterback is one of the 10 returning offensive starters. It’s on his shoulders not to blow it.
Michigan (+) Bringing in an experience quarterback is all that is needed.
Key: + Advantage – No advantage
- Head Coaches and Coordinators
All top teams expected to make the national championship playoffs have top coaching staffs. LSU’s coaches need to get more out of their exceptional players, who flood the NFL yearly. I am betting on it, because their jobs are really on the line this year. Please note that I only give a No. 1 ranking to coaches who have won a national championship.
Coaches Ranking 2016 | ||||
Head Coach | Offensive Coaches | Defensive Coaches | Comments | |
Alabama | 1 | 2 | 2 | Lost top D-coordinator |
Clemson | 2 | 1 | 1 | |
Oklahoma | 2 | 3 | 3 | |
Florida St | 2 | 3 | 2 | |
Ohio State | 1 | 1 | 2 | |
LSU | 3 | 4 | 2 | Coaches underperform |
Michigan | 2 | 3 | 2 |
- Strength of Schedule and Back-to-Back Tough Opponents
Alabama has the toughest schedule based on quality of opponents, the 3 tough games back-to-back, and only 1 of 7 tough games played at home. Stanford and Mississippi are 2 other teams that won’t make the national championship playoffs for similar reasons. Stanford has an unbelievable 5 tough game streak with only 2 of those games at home.
Strength of Schedule Before Championship Playoff | |
Alabama | Toughest – Worse in the nation of top 25 teams; 2 losses |
Clemson | Easy – Weak schedule; no early season tough games |
Oklahoma | Tough – Advantage in getting into playoffs |
Florida St | Mild – Two SEC tough games is an advantage. |
Ohio State | Tough – Oklahoma is big non-conference, an advantage. |
LSU | Tough – Alabama and 3 other tough games are at home. |
Michigan | Easy – Have only 3 tough game; all away |
Back-to-Back Tough Opponents Through Division Championships | ||
Alabama | Tough – At Arkansas, at Tennessee, Texas A&M at home | |
Clemson | Easy – No back-to-back tough games | |
Oklahoma | Easy – One back-to-back tough game series | |
Florida St | Mild – Two back-to-back game series | |
Ohio State | Easy – One back-to-back tough game series | |
LSU | Easy – One back-to-back tough game series | |
Michigan | Easy – One back-to-back tough game series |
Summary
You can see why I have doubts about Alabama, Mississippi and Stanford reaching the national championship playoffs. Also, you may see why Oklahoma and Michigan have the best path to the playoffs. LSU should make it if their coaches and quarterback don’t blow it. Clemson should make it with a powerful offense to balance a slightly weaker defense.
In a Nutshell
“The seasons comes down to these few factors.”
- Alabama – Can they navigate the toughest schedule of the contenders?
- Oklahoma – Can they not stumble “as usual”?
- LSU and Florida State – Can they get enough good quarterback play to defeat Alabama and Clemson?
Easy Does It; Scheduling Easy | ||
Clemson | ||
Michigan | ||
Houston | ||
Tough Schedule; Few Back-To-Back | ||
Oklahoma | ||
LSU | ||
Ohio State | ||
Schedule; Too Tough | ||
Alabama | ||
Mississippi | ||
Stanford |